Lolly
打开应用

创建团队手册与对比

Lolly 与其他工具的比较

Lolly 是同一个开源项目的两个部分。Lolly 是在你的设备上制作、编辑、转换和导出的引擎、应用和工具,无需账号。Lolly Work 是在你自己的基础设施上运行的组织服务器,用于登录、共享项目、审批和服务器渲染。两者都采用 MPL-2.0。本页把这一对与人们设计、管理和制作文件的其他方式进行比较。

核心理念是内容主权:控制内容如何在自己选择的系统之间创建、治理、存储和流转。创意应用可以提供设计,DAM 可以继续作为记录的来源,Lolly 可以把获准的输入和已批准的素材变成新文件。在现有 DAM 中使用 Lolly 介绍了这种组合。

当今的工具

每个圆环为一类产品评分,衡量它对某项能力的完整交付程度,每一类都以其最佳代表来评分。Lolly 列涵盖 Lolly 和 Lolly Work 两者,每一行都说明哪一部分提供什么。点开行名可以看到其评分的理由。各列按顶部的 Overall completeness 行排序:即已评分各行的平均值,不含花费这一行。

这些评分采用的是 Lolly 偏好的标准:无需账号或云端即可掌控。它们是在这些标准下的比较,不是对产品完整度的中立排名,也不是企业采购评分。评估具体工作流时,请分别阅读能力、部署和证据方面的限制。

Lolly includes lolly.work, the same project's separately deployed organisation service. Local creation needs no account; shared work and server rendering use the configured instance. Competitor scores: August 2026. Lolly coverage: 28 September 2026.

Capability Lolly+ lolly.work Penpotopen design CanvaAffinity
Cavalry
Adobedesktop pro Brand DAMFrontify
Bynder
Cloudinarymedia pipeline Figmaonline pro Render APIsBannerbear
Placid
Creatomate
Overall completenessunweighted mean - weight rows for your own context · columns are sorted by this row 84 70 57 48 41 41 41 34
Production maturity & track recordCanva, Adobe, Figma, Bynder/Frontify: a decade-plus at massive scale. Render APIs: years in production pipelines. Penpot: shipping, large community, younger at enterprise scale. Lolly: version 1.0 public since 30 August 2026 under MPL-2.0, and SUSE runs it as an internal deployment; no usage data is shared yet and there are no public case studies yet. Cloudinary: 2012, enterprise media infrastructure at global scale.
25 75 100 100 100 100 100 75
Mass generation from data (CSV / API)Lolly: batch grid and CLI, plus lolly.work's recoverable server jobs and batches with retries, cancellation and retained outputs. Canva: Bulk Create + Autofill API - real, but Enterprise-gated, async, text/image fields only; Affinity Publisher adds desktop data merge. Adobe: InDesign data merge and scripting. Figma: Buzz fills templates from CSV or XLSX, free in beta (Aug 2026) - cloud- and account-gated, 50. Penpot: open API/MCP, not purpose-built. Render APIs: this is their entire product - account- and cloud-gated, so 75 under the method rule. DAM: Studio-style batch create and resize. Cloudinary: URL-driven overlays and named transforms derive variants at scale - account-gated, 75.
100 50 50 50 75 75 50 75
Offline & air-gap operationLolly: standalone creation works offline once its assets are available; lolly.work's organisation services need a reachable instance, which can run on an internal network. The Canva column is scored on its best family member: Affinity (free since Oct 2025) runs offline as a desktop suite once a verified account activates it - 75, the same deduction Adobe takes. Canva's own Offline (2026) still edits pre-synced designs only, per device, in a 14-day window. Adobe: desktop apps run offline; licensing phones home. Figma: cached-file viewing and limited editing. Penpot: self-host on your infra behind a firewall (server required). Cloud APIs and DAM: none.
100 75 75 75 0 0 25 0
On-device rendering - data never leavesLolly: local rendering and conversion in-browser or CLI need no upload. Choosing lolly.work's shared storage, work collabs or server rendering sends the relevant data to the configured instance. Adobe: local desktop rendering, but cloud services and telemetry in the suite. Figma: canvas renders locally, files live in Figma's cloud. Penpot: 90 - rendering happens in the browser and the save target is a server that can be your own sovereign private cloud, even your own laptop, with private export throughout; only the server hop separates it from Lolly. Canva itself is server-side by design; the column's 75 is Affinity - local desktop rendering, account activation and telemetry, the same shape as Adobe. Render APIs, DAM: server-side by design.
100 90 75 75 0 0 25 0
Hard brand constraints (structural)Lolly: templates fix layout rules and expose permitted inputs. lolly.work adds group access, input policies, shared catalogues, approvals and audit records. Copy and usage rights can still need review. Canva: element locks - permission-based, admin-set and static: no template logic such as conditional logo switching or responsive recomposition at fill time, and Canva AI does not yet respect Brand Controls - 50. Render APIs: templates are fixed (only declared fields vary) but no governance layer. DAM: locked templates with restrictions. Figma: Buzz templates hold locked guidelines at fill time; the design surface stays review-enforced - 50. Penpot: tokens and systems enforced by review, not runtime. Adobe: libraries, little enforcement. Cloudinary: presets and Enterprise-gated transformation templates fix operations, not brand layout - 50.
100 50 50 25 75 50 50 75
C2PA provenance, signed at creationAdobe: the broadest shipped implementation (Photoshop, Lightroom, Premiere, Firefly) - signing happens locally in the desktop apps and in the cloud for the Content Authenticity web app, and nothing signs without an Adobe account and an Adobe-provisioned identity, so it is account-gated end to end: 75 under the method rule. Lolly: optional on-device signing without an account, plus lolly.work server signing with a configured organisation identity. A verifier must trust the signer's root to show a trusted identity. Version 1.0 is public and SUSE runs it internally, but no usage data is shared yet, so 75. Penpot: 50 via the official Lolly Export plugin - the same on-device engine signing Lolly uses, opt-in, as in Lolly (and disclosed plainly: it is Lolly's own plugin). No evidence of C2PA writing in Canva, Figma, render APIs or DAM as of Aug 2026. Cloudinary: 50 - signs images on delivery (fl_c2pa, CAI member since 2020), attesting delivery by Cloudinary rather than creation by you.
75 50 0 75 0 50 0 0
CLI, pipeline & AI-agent automationLolly: CLI, TUI, MCP server and URL mode, plus lolly.work's authenticated render API, recoverable batches and governed delivery. One engine across the local and server paths. Render APIs: API-first, webhooks, integrations - account- and cloud-gated, so 75 under the method rule. Penpot: open API, plugins, official MCP server. Canva: Connect API - Enterprise-gated, async, rate-limited. Adobe: UXP/ExtendScript plus Firefly APIs. Figma: strong REST/plugin API, no render pipeline. DAM: asset-management APIs. Cloudinary: API-first media pipeline - account-gated, 75.
100 75 50 50 50 75 50 75
Live collaboration (real-time co-editing)Figma: the scale benchmark - 200 simultaneous editors, up to 500 people in a file - account and cloud required. Canva: mature real-time editing across the product, same precondition. Penpot: real-time multiplayer with live cursors; self-hosting lifts the vendor-account precondition, but a server is still required. Lolly: direct two-device private collabs without an account, plus authenticated work collabs through lolly.work with shared edits, cursors and saved team sessions. Partial reflects the current single-node work deployment and limited operating history. Private collabs work without internet on a shared network; work collabs need the organisation's instance. Adobe: Live Co-Editing in beta, cloud documents only. Render APIs: no editing surface. DAM: comments and approvals, not canvas co-editing. Cloudinary: DAM comments and workflows, no canvas co-editing.
50 75 75 25 25 25 75 0
No design skill requiredCanva: the category benchmark for ease. DAM: fill a locked template. Lolly: fill in fields using an existing tool, or publish a tool from Lolly Design through Share with rules. lolly.work manages access and input policy for the team. Render APIs: swaps design skill for developer skill. Adobe, Figma, Penpot: professional tools. Cloudinary: the media library is easy; transformations are developer territory.
100 25 100 25 100 50 25 50
Open source, self-hosted, no lock-inPenpot: MPL-licensed, 51k+ stars, self-host via Docker/K8s - fully verifiable today. Lolly and lolly.work: MPL-2.0 open source in separate repositories, both self-hostable. lolly.work provides the organisation services as part of the project. The current 75 reflects the young project and limited deployment history. Everything else is proprietary SaaS or proprietary desktop.
75 100 0 0 0 0 0 0
Cost at production scaleLolly + lolly.work and Penpot: no per-seat software licence charge for the open-source self-hosted path; hardware, storage and operations remain costs. Render APIs: metered - roughly $0.005–0.049 per image, credits often expiring monthly. Canva/Figma: per-seat; Canva's automation needs Enterprise, though Affinity itself is free since Oct 2025. Adobe: premium per-seat suite. DAM: sales-led enterprise quotes, MAU or seat models. Cloudinary: credit-metered across transforms, storage and bandwidth - 25.
100 100 50 25 25 25 50 25
Annual medium enterprise spendIndicative list-price arithmetic for a medium enterprise - think 500-5000 people - August 2026: a guess range, not a quote; deals vary and the seat mix dominates. Ring = how much of the board's largest annual spend (US$500k) you keep; the number in the ring is each range's upper bound. Canva (US$75k-400k; Affinity free since Oct 2025 pulls the design-seat share down), Adobe (US$100k-500k) and Figma (US$30k-250k) assume the realistic creative-seat share of an organisation this size - tens to hundreds of seats, not a licence for every employee. Render APIs price by usage (US$5k-60k). DAM is quote-only, commonly US$50k-250k and up. Penpot is hand-set at 99: "your server" can be your own laptop - a small technical hurdle at well under 1% of an Adobe-scale spend. Lolly + lolly.work: US$0 in software licence charges for self-hosting. The figure excludes devices, organisation hosting, storage, support and administration; these need a separate budget. Standalone Lolly does not need the organisation service. Cloudinary: US$30k-150k, credit-based; enterprise contracts commonly sit near US$82k.
$0 $0 $400k $500k $250k+ $150k $250k $60k

能力对比:竞品调研和评分截至 2026 年 8 月;Lolly + Lolly Work 的覆盖情况于 2026 年 9 月 28 日审阅。评分:0 缺失,25 勉强可用,50 真实但受限或不完整,75 强但有保留,100 核心竞争力。

signed by Lollypositioning-comparison.htmlHTMLpixels, not shapes40 KBAI editedgenerated by GPT-6Check it yourself获取已签名文件
评分说明

可用的功能与生产成熟度是两回事。Lolly 已经发布:1.0 版本于 2026 年 8 月 30 日以开源形式发布,其安全性尚未经过独立审计,其采用证据只有几个月(采用与治理有当前状态)。具备单点登录、审批或服务器渲染并不能证明生产环境的长期记录,所以成熟度评分反映了这一点。竞品评分保持其带日期的 8 月评审。

有一条规则管着整张表。对于涉及你的内容或身份的行,满分(100)需要一项无需账号、无需云端前提即可使用的能力;关于产品本身的行,例如成熟度和易用性,则不受此限。这条规则让 Adobe 在 Content Credentials 上失分:它是已出货的最广泛的实现(Photoshop、Lightroom、Premiere、Firefly),在本地和云端签名,但从不脱离 Adobe 账号和身份,所以是 75。出于同样的原因,它也让渲染 API 在批量生成和自动化上封顶。

Canva 的每一行都以其最佳的家族成员评分,因为它拥有 Affinity 和 Cavalry(两者都在 2025 年 10 月免费放出)。离线和设备端渲染通过 Affinity 得到 75,这是一套仍需要已验证账号并带有遥测的桌面套件,Adobe 也被扣了同样的分;Canva 自己的离线模式只能在一台设备上、在有限的时间窗口内编辑预先同步的设计。Autofill 得 50:它是真实的,但仅限 Enterprise 且是异步的,只填充文字和图片。Figma 的批量生成从 25 升到 50,因为 Buzz 推出了电子表格填充(2026 年 8 月的免费测试版)。

Lolly 的 Content Credentials 得分 75,涵盖设备端签名和 Lolly Work 以已配置的组织身份进行的服务器签名;验证者仍必须信任签名者(Content Credentials 身份)。Penpot 的 50 来自 Lolly 自己的 Penpot 导出插件:同样的引擎签名,选择加入并像 Lolly 的一样披露。Penpot 在设备端渲染上得 90:浏览器画布,保存目标是它的服务器,而这个服务器可以自托管。Cloudinary 因其素材库、转换 API 和 CDN 而有自己的一列;8 月评审给它的交付签名打了 50 分。

Lolly 的实时协作包括两台设备之间直接的私密协作,以及通过 Lolly Work 进行的经过认证的工作协作,带有共享编辑、光标和保存的团队会话。Partial 评分反映的是目前单节点的 Lolly Work 部署和较短的运营历史,而不是缺少团队编辑。价格估算是带日期的标价算术,用于了解量级,不是采购依据。

什么时候选择 Lolly

在以下情况选择 Lolly

  • 反复需要同一类文件:活动方块、证件、证书、提醒、社交卡片
  • 许多文件来自一个模板和一张值的表格,使用 Lolly Batch 或 CLI
  • 颜色、字体和素材必须留在设计系统之内,即使在开放的画布上
  • 一份完成的 Figma、Penpot、Illustrator、InDesign 或 PDF 设计应该变得可编辑、可重复(导入设计)
  • 文件必须在你自己的设备或服务器上制作

在以下情况选择别的

  • 工作是精细的照片修饰或插画
  • 你在设计和原型制作应用界面
  • 你第一天就需要一个庞大的素材库和模板库
  • 你需要一项在大规模上有长期记录的托管服务

导入的设计和共享的设计令牌让团队可以把 Lolly 与专业应用结合使用,而 Lolly Work 管控共享素材、审阅和交付。

对于有精心管理的 DAM 的团队,先保持该素材库及其管理员不变。SUSE 的 Brandfolder 经验记录了集成如何支持采用和审批的变更管理。DAM 厂商和实施合作伙伴可以通过合作伙伴工作流评估同样的安排。

一整套幻灯片演示稿显示了上限:在 Lolly Markdown Slides 中,演示稿被声明为数据,实时排版,并导出为原生可编辑的 PowerPoint 文件。

分栏视图中的 Lolly Markdown Slides:左侧以块的形式列出演示稿的幻灯片,右侧是排好版的演示稿渲染 signed by Lollyvector SVG135 paths~17k nodes252 groups1 image226 KBCheck it yourself获取已签名文件分栏视图中的 Lolly Markdown Slides:左侧以块的形式列出演示稿的幻灯片,右侧是排好版的演示稿渲染 signed by Lollyvector SVG128 paths~17k nodes252 groups1 image225 KBCheck it yourself获取已签名文件

规则存在于工具中

Lolly 把可复用的品牌规则放进工具:颜色、字体、出血边距、间距和允许的输入项。模板固定了接收者不得更改的部分。Lolly Work 在该模板周围增加组访问和输入政策,并为目录提交和交付配备审批链。

检查一次工具会让重复的生产更容易,因为每个输出都继承其版面规则。文案、上传的图像和使用权仍然可能需要检查,Lolly Work 为此提供共享目录和审批步骤。对创意团队来说,工具是护栏:你仍然带来数据、文案和图像,工具让每个结果都符合品牌。

制作者的全部工作:输入文字。字体、颜色和间距在制作该工具时就已确定 signed by Lollyvector SVG121 paths~4.6k nodes197 groups2 images113 KBCheck it yourself获取已签名文件

还有三点让这种做法与众不同:

大胆的设计经得起护栏。这幅海报级的城市地图是真正的矢量道路和水域路径,来自一个下拉菜单和两个颜色字段,它们无法被指向设计系统之外:

阿姆斯特丹的运河环和道路网,以设计系统自己的墨色一直画到边缘,每一笔都由模板而不是手工放置 signed by Lollyvector SVG8 paths~25k nodes7 groups287 KBCheck it yourself获取已签名文件阿姆斯特丹的运河环和道路网,以设计系统自己的墨色一直画到边缘,每一笔都由模板而不是手工放置 signed by Lollyvector SVG8 paths~25k nodes7 groups287 KBCheck it yourself获取已签名文件

概率式创新,确定性规模化

大多数“AI 创意”的推销都把模型放在了一条古老界线的错误一侧。抄写员和彩饰师早就划定了这条线在哪里。你在草图阶段随意发挥,在那里什么都可以尝试,什么都不必定下来。然后你走向印刷机,印刷机负责定稿。艺术在草图里,印刷机是它传播的方式,印出来的作品之所以可信,是因为印刷机每一次印制都兑现了它的承诺。

Lolly 就是印刷机。你可以带着任何东西来构思,模型、设计师或一张草图,但一旦一个想法要变成许多文件,它就要经过某个每次都以同样方式渲染的东西,其输入任何人都可以读回。上面的对比,说到底是在比较谁让这个定稿的步骤可重复。

信任创意过程,以严谨实现规模化。

永远免费

只要它在你的设备上渲染,就永远免费。 引擎、外壳、工具和格式都是开源的,已发布的版本无法被收回。Lolly Work 也是开源的。组织为自己选择的基础设施和运营付费,自托管没有按席位或按渲染次数收取的软件许可费用。问答讲述了这个承诺背后的故事。

你的内容存放在哪里

Lolly 的创意工作可以在你自己拥有的硬件上运行,它的设计令牌、字体、徽标和工具都是你可以保存的文件。使用 Lolly Work 时,共享项目、素材、政策和审计记录存放在你的组织配置的存储中。信任解释了这为什么重要,隐私政策和自行验证让你去检验这一说法,而不是只听我们说。

逐个工具对比

逐个工具对比 Lolly把 Lolly 与 Canva、Adobe、Figma、Penpot、品牌门户、渲染 API 和在线转换器逐个对比,每个一页,并列出了什么在哪里运行。